Mt Everest K2 Comparison Essay

In September 2010, after hearing mountain climber Gerlinde Kaltenbrunner talk about the difficulties of a recent expedition up K2, one being gaps in her knowledge of the terrain, earth scientist Stefan Dech had an idea to turn satellite data into a three-dimensional map of the mountain.

Two months later, Dech, a director at Germany's Earth Observation Center, found himself in an animation lab, "flying" over the Baltoro Glacier to the summit of K2, then turning around and looking down the north ridge, into the Shaksgam Valley below. The new imagery gave an unprecedented level of precision for scientists—and future climbers—to see every position, every upward trail, and every possible route for a virtual climb along to the summit, the most difficult of all the 8,000-meter peaks.

In the years since, he and his colleagues have collaborated with their French counterpart, the Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales (CNES), and the Airbus Group to take data from the Pléiades satellites and create intricate terrain models of 13 mountains in all. These models have been turned into photorealistic views from perspectives and heights never possible before.

Now they are all collected in a new book, Mountains: Mapping the Earth’s Extremes (Thames & Hudson, 2016). Inside, Bech writes that it will “give nature-lovers, mountain-lovers, and ambitious climbers a new and inspiring way to access to the great mountains of the world without leaving their armchairs.” Here's a sample.

K2, Chinese Qogir Feng, also called Mount Godwin Austen, called locally Dapsang or Chogori, the world’s second highest peak (28,251 feet [8,611 metres]), second only to Mount Everest. K2 is located in the Karakoram Range and lies partly in a Chinese-administered enclave of the Kashmir region within the Uygur Autonomous Region of Xinjiang, China, and partly in the Gilgit-Baltistan portion of Kashmir under the administration of Pakistan.

The glacier- and snow-covered mountain rises from its base at about 15,000 feet (4,570 metres) on the Godwin Austen Glacier, a tributary of the Baltoro Glacier. The mountain was discovered in 1856 by Col. T.G. Montgomerie of the Survey of India, and it was given the symbol K2 because it was the second peak measured in the Karakoram Range. The name Mount Godwin Austen is for the peak’s first surveyor, Col. H.H. Godwin Austen, a 19th-century English geographer.

The first attempt to reach the summit was made by an Anglo-Swiss expedition in 1902 that ascended to 18,600 feet (5,670 metres) on the peak’s northeastern crest. Other unsuccessful attempts included an Italian expedition in 1909, led by Luigi Amedeo, duke d’Abruzzi, via the southeastern ridge (later called the Abruzzi Ridge) that reached approximately 20,000 feet (6,100 metres). In 1938 an American expedition led by Charles Houston via the Abruzzi Ridge reached about 26,000 feet (7,925 metres); in 1939 another American-led expedition following the same route reached about 27,500 feet (8,380 metres); and in 1953 another expedition led by Houston reached 25,900 feet (7,900 metres) on the Abruzzi Ridge. Finally, in 1954, an Italian expedition consisting of five scientists (including the geologist Ardito Desio as leader), a doctor, a photographer, and 12 others, including a Pakistani, managed to conquer the Abruzzi Ridge despite the severe weather conditions. The summit was reached at 6 pm on July 31, 1954, by Achille Compagnoni and Lino Lacedelli. In the course of the ascent, Mario Puchoz, one of the guides, died of pneumonia.

Because K2 is prone to frequent and severe storms that make the already treacherous climbing conditions on its slopes even more challenging—and humans find functioning at such high elevations difficult—it is one of the world’s most difficult mountains to climb. The number of people to have reached the top constitutes only a small fraction compared with how many have successfully climbed Mount Everest. In addition, although there have been fewer deaths on K2 compared with those on Mount Everest, the proportion of those killed to the number of people who have attempted climbing K2 is significantly higher.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *